The only problem with this theory is that if they had no knowledge of germs, Stannis would not understand how the doll was responsible for the greyscale. We aim to give research-driven, smart, and accessible information to everyone who wants it. We also learned from Sam's reading, and from earlier info in the books and show, that there is a ton of dragonglass on Dragonstone. Why did they burn the child in Game of Thrones? Two Characters Were Cured Of Greyscale In Game Of Thrones. 21. Related: Game of Thrones: Why Ned Stark and Robert Baratheon Rebelled. Remove the infected area, plaster with a salve that kills the greyscale germs. And yet . The doll was from a Dornish trader. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, http://gameofthrones.wikia.com/wiki/Shireen_Baratheon. We must rely only on what we've seen onscreen (or read in the books that Game of Thrones is based on) to attempt a diagnosis. How Did Shireen Get Greyscale? Movie News, Movie Trailers & upcoming Movie Reviews, The Leading Source for Gaming News, Reviews, and Interviews, Game Of Thrones: Greyscale Explained (& How It Can Be Cured), Game of Thrones: Why Ned Stark and Robert Baratheon Rebelled, Complete House Of The Dragon Guide: All Your Questions Answered, The Biggest Changes To The Book In House Of The Dragon Season 1, All Jacked Up And Full Of Worms Review: A Creative But Aimless Midnight Movie, Falling For Christmas Review: Lohan Dazzles In By-The-Numbers Christmas Rom-Com, Paradise City Review: Willis & Travolta Reunite In Disappointing Action Thriller, MVP Review: Army Green Beret Nate Boyer Pens & Stars In Underbaked Directorial Debut, The Friendship Game Review: Frustrating Horror Mystery Feels Like a Messy Rough Draft, Black Panther: Wakanda Forever Review - A Fitting, Ambitious Tribute To An Icon, John Wick 4 Trailer Reveals How Keanu Reeves Can Escape High Table, Renegades Trailer Showcases A Bloody Tale Of Vengeance [EXCLUSIVE], High Heat Trailer Highlights A Kitchen To Die For [EXCLUSIVE], Brendan Fraser's Comeback Role Revealed In The Whale Trailer, Knives Out 2 Trailer Teases Glass Onion's Murder Mystery Game Gone Wrong, Avatar 2 Trailer: James Cameron's Incredible Underwater CGI Meets Genuine Emotion, The Conners Is Setting Up The Biggest Tragedy Since Roseanne Died, Explaining Those Shots Of Syrax During Rhaenyra's Miscarriage, House Of The Dragon AI Images Imagine Book-Accurate Character Designs. Greyscale is considered a fate worse than death in Westeros, and rightly so. Eagle-eyed viewers noticed that last season, during the episode "The Lion And The Rose," Melisandre and Shireen had a conversation during which the Red Priestess touched the princess's face: Many viewers likely didn't think much of it then, because the concept of greyscale was much hazier a year ago. Greyscale, also known as " Prince Garin 's curse " [1], is a dreaded and usually fatal disease that can leave flesh stiff and dead, and the skin cracked and flaking, and stone-like to the touch. Pus (the viscous yellow-white fluid composed of white blood cells, tissue debris, and infection) can be caused by any of these types of infectious agents, though it is most common with bacterial infections and some viral infections (herpes viruses). All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. It seems to be a disease, not some form of contact poison. Below is an excerpt of the conversation from the books between Val (Free Folk/Wildling Princess) & Jon Snow, regarding what is common/popular knowledge of greyscale amongst woods witches. newsletter. Stannis definitely deserves a harsh punishment for his part in Shireen's death, but, if the books are any indication, his fate may already be sealed anyway. Shireen is Stannis's only living daughter and therefore his heir presumptive. As for Jorah, Daenerys Targaryen forced him to relieve his duties in her army so that he could find a cure before it was too late. Stannis gets up from his table and explains that not long after Shireen was born, a Dornish trader arrived on Dragonstone and, having heard of Shireen's birth, gave a wooden doll as a gift for the newborn girl. by Victoria McNally. Man and mineral is simply a bad combo. The fires of her faith cleanse and protect her and all that nonsense. They become extremely contagious and must be quarantined. Calling book experts if someone can enlighten us on the topic Greyscale. 2) What kind of infectious agent might cause greyscale? Greyscale may also have been transmitted by a childs doll, as seen in the case of. You can also contribute via. I believe "targeting" was for easy coin. In the next sentence Shireen is hugging the doll. She had three older brothers, who were stillborn . But why Stannis and Shireen, surly theres better targets if the doll was a revenge plot against the Baratheons. If Jorah did infect Dany, then it stands to reason that Shireen could have also infected Melisandre, right? Poor Princess Shireen was about as innocent and pure as a character living in Westeros can be. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. From the available evidence, greyscale would seem an insidious infection that is most likely caused by a smallpox or HPV-like virus. We can't surmise everything from that, but we can make a good guess. His only child is a daughter, making his bid for the Iron Throne an exercise in futility by Westerosi standards. Until last week, it was easy to figure out who to root for in the upcoming battle at Winterfell between King Stannis Baratheon and the despicable Boltons. Please enter a valid email and try again. Last episode they were practically spelling it out. So in a Dance with Dragons when Jon introduces Val to Queen Selyse Val is horrified at Shireen. Although not verified, the Archmaester at the Citadel told Jorah that he could live 10 or 20 years with the disease but would likely lose his mind in six months, if not sooner. Here are the three most likely to cause problems: In Jorah's case, greyscale appeared at the inoculation site within a day, suggesting rapid transmission without penetrating injury. In Season 5, Episode 4 titled Sons of the Harpy, Stannis Baratheon explains to Shireen how she contracted greyscale when she was an infant:. According to the Archmaester at the Citadel, the key to stopping the disease from spreading is immediate treatment. Jorah was infected with the disease . Crap shoot. You lose a lot of detail by only watching the show. HBO. Aside from White Walkers, wights, and other deadly enemies, the characters in Game of Thrones also had to steer clear of the fatal disease known as Greyscale. Plotting Shireen's murder doesn't make any sence. Game of Thrones has only revealed a few afflicted patients onscreen, but this handful of cases provides an opportunity to investigate what causes the mysterious illness. You're reading too much into the conversation. While Jorah is actively suffering from greyscale, Shireen had already survived the disease. Most likely, a tragic accident. What did The Treasure do in the books? Stannis and Selyse are rarely intimate. With time, patients with advanced greyscale develop aggressive, even psychotic behavior. Grayscale would be a pretty damn volatile and unpredictable way of murdering someone, and Shireen is not a threat to anyone. You don't see that a lot. Just a thought. Sounded like revenge for taking their land to me. The late Shireen, who caught greyscale as a baby through an infected doll she held to her face, solely had the remnants of the rash on the left side of her face.Unlike most people who get greyscale, the princess was cured. Something went wrong. Fleas in fabric shipments from China carrying the Black Plague. Greyscale was a deadly threat to the characters in Game of Thrones. It does not appear to be spread by respiratory droplets (coughing/sneezing) or sex (though, presumably, having sex with someone with greyscale would involve physical touch). Although it does make me think something horrible will happen to him. There is theory and implied that targs cant get greyscale another clue pointed towards tryrion being targ. Megabank Morgan Stanley has purchased 28,289 shares of Grayscale Bitcoin Trust through its Europe Opportunity Fund, according to a U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission filing. How did Shireen get greyscale; TV Medicine: Game Of Bones S07E02; What Is Greyscale? And people can be carriers without symptoms a'la Typhoid Mary. He explicitly states that Shireen pressed the doll to her cheek, and soon after became infected with greyscale. Shireen is on Dragonstone with her father, Stannis, and mother, Selyse.Maester Cressen pities the sad-looking child, and has his assistant, Maester Pylos, show her the white raven that has arrived from the Citadel to announce the onset of autumn.Shireen tells Cressen about her nightmares that dragons are coming to eat her, and he tries to reassure her, saying that the stone dragons of . I still don't know what the bloody purpose of greyscale will be, in the books or show, just for the record. Which Finger is the (Spoilers Extended) Elia Martell was not okay with (Spoilers main) Why is Robert/Joffrey's Kingsguard so [Spoilers Main] The reason GRRM is taking a while with (Spoilers Extended) What's a small thing from the books Found this in a free book box , Printed 1998 (no spoilers). Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. We accept credit card, Apple Pay, and The dreaded condition is a slow and maddening death sentence from which none in Westeros are immune. One was the rightful heir to the Iron Throne, attempting to protect the Seven Kingdoms from the impending White Walker invasion; the other was a family of mustache-twirling villains who organize wedding massacres and assault their wives on their wedding nights. In the final episode of the HBO series' fifth season, Stannis Baratheon (Stephen Dillane) was killed by Brienne of Tarth (Gwendoline Christie) who was fulfilling her sworn oath of avenging the death of his brother, Renly.. Who killed Renly? News and discussions relating to George R. R. Martin's "A Song of Ice and Fire" novels, his Westeros-based short stories, the "Game of Thrones" and "House of the Dragon" TV series, and all things ASOIAF - but with particular emphasis on the written series. Yes, I believe Shireen's greyscale was cured because she lives on a dragonglass island, just like I believe Jojen's greywater fever was cured because he lives in a basalt swamp. Given that the infectious agent must be transmissible skin to skin, develop quickly, and survive on fabric, the most likely candidate would be a virus. New father is an easy target to make a sale on. It's possible Crabfeeder might've been cured in time if Daemon didn't use the Valyrian steel sword Dark Sister to slice his body in half. Does Ser Jorah find a cure? That would take SO LONG to kill her. Anthrax, another gram-positive bacteria like staph and strep, is easily transmitted and can spread from contact with the skin (and through inhalation or through the gastrointestinal tract), but not skin to skin. After graduating college, writing began as a part-time hobby for Kara, but it quickly turned into a career. MRSA from improperly sanitized surfaces in hospitals. Perhaps only certain cells in Shireens skin were susceptible to infection, and maybe that is why progression of her disease was halted, rather than by the magic of her father's wizards, who are generally given credit for her condition's control. In any case, I severely doubt it was a plot to kill Shireen. Sadly, though, that's not the case. The daughter of Game of Thrones villain Stannis Baratheon became infected when she was an infant. Maybe it was just some kind of accident? 8. Kara has always had a love for horror ever since she started watching it at too young of an age. Interestingly, in recent years in the United States, cases of leprosy in Florida, Texas, and Louisiana have been reported in patients that had one thing in common: contact with armadillos. The late Shireen, who caught greyscale as a baby through an infected doll she held to her face, solely had the remnants of the rash on the left side of her face.Unlike most people who get greyscale, the princess was cured. It's easier to believe a society without knowledge of germs would buy and sell contaminated goods. Perhaps the pattern on Shireen Baratheons face occurred because of the acuity of her treatment, which occurred immediately upon discovery of her condition and seemingly halted the infection from progressing. How a surprising Democratic strategy may have staved off the midterm red wave, Sign up for the Even Ned talked about marrying off Sansa and Arya like that was their expected duty. Stannis says that the merchant is likely just trying to score an easy sell by targeting a new father - he's skeptical of anyone who tries to curry favor by appealing to emotions. To make a diagnosis, lets consider five separate questions. But, could it happen sooner than we think? It's intimated he murdered them to put them out of their misery. Such a virus could be easily transmitted skin to skin. I read that as the merchant "targeting" fathers for an easy sell. Greyscale starts with skin changes that begin where the patient was touched (the inoculation site). How come Stannis didn't get greyscale too? The dying Stannis is shortly thereafter located by Brienne of Tarth, once kingsguard to Renly, who executes him for the murder of his younger brother. Bacteria, such as staph and strep. This might have been obvious to most people here, but I missed it on the first watch. The fact that the show and books both have a potential patient zero in Westeros means it is probably important, and logic dictates it relates to dragons or Others somehow, but I can't see a way for that to work as of yet. Yeah, I like how the show's making Stannis a likeable character. And yet, he loves her unconditionally. She needs to die much sooner and hopefully much more painfully than that. Answer (1 of 6): Secluded is said to have contracted greyscale as an infant. In time, the Greyscale would spread from head to toe before affecting vital organs and the brain, eventually turning the victim mad. While were committed to keeping Vox free, our distinctive brand of explanatory journalism does take a lot of resources. One final word of warning: If isolated, the infectious agent in greyscale would be a bioterrorism risk. I can't remember. The Crabfeeder suffered from Greyscale before Daemon "cured" him using Valyrian steel. He explicitly states that Shireen pressed the doll to her cheek, and soon after became infected with greyscale. The answer it turns out is something we here in the 21st century take for granted: Plain old germ theory. It remains unclear if any treatments for greyscale are effective, aside from some wizardry. To me, this suggests that the doll was "infected" with greyscale, and was sold to Stannis with the intention of murdering his heir. I don't think there was a plot to murder his heir twelve years ago/however old Shireen is, because theoretically his line would never rule assuming Robert had legitimate heirs. Reader gifts support this mission by helping to keep our work free whether were adding nuanced context to unexpected events or explaining how our democracy got to this point. A Forum of Ice and Fire A Song of Ice and Fire & Game of Thrones Why did Stannis Baratheon die? The deterioration was known to take years before victims succumbed to the infectious disease. Notably, Craghas Crabfeeder didn't wear a mask nor did he have Greyscale in the book Fire & Blood.

Northern District Of Georgia Judges, Oracle Eloqua Vs Responsys, Marrying Outside Of Your Culture Is Called, 1up Games Near Prague, House Of Delegates District 10 Candidates,